Appeals Court Rules House Passed 1.7 Trillion Dollar Bill Unconstitutionally by Proxy Vote
The United States House of Representatives unconstitutionally passed a 1.7 trillion dollar government funding bill in 2022 through a pandemic era rule that allowed lawmakers to vote by proxy rather than in person, and according to reports a federal appeals court ruled on Friday by a 9 to 8 vote. The New Orleans based 5th United States Circuit Court of Appeals upheld an injunction that Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton secured blocking enforcement of a provision of that measure that gave pregnant workers stronger legal protections.
The Quorum Clause at the Centre
The ruling, powered by the court conservative majority, held that the proxy rule violated the Constitution quorum clause, which the court said requires a majority of House members to be physically present to pass legislation. The bill passed the House on a 225 to 201 vote, with 226 members voting by proxy, a figure that shows how heavily the chamber relied on remote voting at the time. The proxy rule was ditched when Republicans took control of the House after the November 2022 elections.
The provision at the heart of the case is the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which strengthened legal protections for pregnant workers. Paxton, the outgoing Republican attorney general of Texas, challenged the measure, and the court agreed that the way the wider spending package was passed made its adoption unconstitutional. United States Circuit Judge James Graves, an appointee of Democratic President Barack Obama, dissented from the ruling and called its reasoning into question.
Narrow Relief, Wide Implications
While the decision concerns how the entire bill was passed, the relief the court granted was narrow. It barred the United States Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant workers provision against Texas, rather than striking down the whole spending package. That distinction matters, because a broader ruling would have thrown years of federal spending into doubt.
Even so, the ruling raises fresh questions about pandemic era procedures and about how far courts are willing to go in policing the internal rules of Congress. The case is likely to draw further legal challenges, and the Justice Department will now have to decide whether to seek review. On Friday, the court sent a clear message that remote voting cannot substitute for the physical presence the Constitution quorum clause demands.

